Overview of TransGAN
TransGAN is the first generative adversarial network (GAN) in the world to be built entirely on a pure Transformer architecture, without relying on any convolutional neural networks (CNNs).
-
Paper title: TransGAN: Two Transformers Can Make One Strong GAN
-
Authors: Yifan Jiang et al.
-
Conference: NeurIPS 2021
-
Key feature: A GAN composed solely of Transformers, without any use of CNNs
Traditionally, most GANs have been based on CNNs, as local convolutional operations were considered essential for effective image generation. TransGAN breaks this convention by demonstrating that self-attention mechanisms alone can achieve high-quality image generation, drawing significant attention in the research community.
The architecture of TransGAN consists of two main Transformer-based components: a Generator and a Discriminator.
The Generator takes a noise vector sampled from a standard Gaussian distribution as input. This vector is transformed into patch-like feature tokens, which are then passed through multiple Transformer encoder blocks to learn the image structure. The output tokens are finally merged and linearly projected to produce an image.
The Discriminator, on the other hand, divides the input image into small patches, treats each as a token, and processes them using a structure similar to a Vision Transformer (ViT) to determine whether the image is real or fake.
The architecture incorporates several Transformer-specific innovations, including:
-
Patch-based input representation (as in ViT)
-
Positional encoding to preserve spatial information
-
Stabilization techniques such as Layer Normalization and GELU
-
Optimizations for data-efficient training, enabling learning from limited datasets
-
Stabilization mechanisms for GAN training, including spectral normalization, tailored loss functions, and warm-up schedules
In terms of performance, TransGAN has been evaluated on benchmark datasets such as CIFAR-10, CelebA, and LSUN, achieving results comparable to or even surpassing traditional CNN-based models like DCGAN and StyleGAN. This validates that Transformers alone are capable of high-quality image synthesis, marking a pivotal moment in generative modeling.
TransGAN is also notable for its relationship to other Transformer-based models such as ViT, GANformer, and non-GAN models like Image GPT and DALL·E. Among these, TransGAN stands out for pioneering the intersection of Self-Attention and image generation, establishing itself as a foundational work in the evolution of Transformer-based generative models.
Related Algorithm
1. Transformer × Image Generation
In recent years, many models have emerged that apply Transformer architectures to image generation. Unlike traditional CNN-based methods, these approaches treat images as sequences of tokens, opening up new possibilities in visual synthesis. TransGAN is a pioneering model in this context. Below are related models and how they relate to TransGAN:
▪️ Vision Transformer (ViT)
A Transformer model that processes images by dividing them into small patches, mainly used for classification tasks.
-
Relation to TransGAN: The discriminator in TransGAN is inspired by ViT and adopts a similar patch-based structure and self-attention mechanism.
▪️ Image GPT
Processes images as token sequences and generates them in an auto-regressive manner.
-
Relation to TransGAN: Although not a GAN, Image GPT was one of the earliest models to show that Transformers can be used for image generation, paving the way for TransGAN.
▪️ DALL·E / DALL·E 2
Generates images from text input using a combination of Transformer and diffusion models.
-
Relation to TransGAN: While fundamentally different in generation mechanism (non-adversarial), they belong to the same broader class of Transformer-based generation models.
▪️ GANformer
A hybrid GAN architecture combining self-attention and cross-attention mechanisms.
-
Relation to TransGAN: Both aim to integrate Transformers into GANs, but GANformer features more complex attention dynamics focused on preserving semantic structure.
▪️ Styleformer
A Transformer-based variant of StyleGAN with style control capabilities.
-
Relation to TransGAN: While TransGAN emphasizes pure Transformer-based generation, Styleformer focuses on high-fidelity image synthesis with controllable style, marking a more advanced, specialized direction.
These models collectively demonstrate that Transformers are highly effective not only in natural language processing but also in visual generation tasks. Among them, TransGAN is distinguished as the first fully Transformer-based GAN, proving that high-quality image generation is possible without relying on CNNs.
2. Transformer × GAN Models (Same Objective)
TransGAN inspired a wave of Transformer-GAN architectures. These models aim to increase flexibility, precision, and conditional generation capability by moving beyond CNNs or combining them with Transformer components.
▪️ TransGAN
-
Feature: Entirely constructed with Transformers, no CNN involved.
-
Note: The first pure Transformer-based GAN, introducing self-attention in both generator and discriminator.
▪️ ViTGAN
-
Feature: Incorporates a ViT-like structure in the discriminator, with a differently designed generator.
-
Note: Focuses more on classification accuracy, with a structural concept similar to TransGAN.
▪️ StyleSwin
-
Feature: Uses Swin Transformer (shifted windows) for high-resolution image generation.
-
Note: A more recent model with strong style control and local-global feature handling, serving as a hybrid of StyleGAN and Transformer.
▪️ T2I-Adapter + GAN
-
Feature: Combines Transformer-based T2I-Adapter with GAN for text-to-image generation.
-
Note: Extends the generation task into conditional and multimodal domains, using Transformers for contextual understanding and GANs for visual synthesis.
These models reflect different evolutionary paths in Transformer × GAN development:
-
TransGAN laid the groundwork with its bold CNN-free design,
-
ViTGAN refined discriminator performance,
-
StyleSwin enhanced visual fidelity and detail,
-
T2I-Adapter + GAN expanded into conditional and multimodal generation.
Collectively, they represent not just architectural variants, but a broader evolutionary trajectory leveraging the flexibility of Transformers in GAN design.
3. Traditional CNN-based GANs (Comparison & Influence)
Prior to TransGAN, most image generation GANs were built around CNNs. These models formed the technological foundation for high-quality synthesis and served as comparison points, structural references, and conceptual baselinesfor Transformer-based models like TransGAN.
▪️ DCGAN (Deep Convolutional GAN)
-
Overview: One of the simplest and most widely used CNN-based GAN architectures.
-
Relation to TransGAN: Often used as a baseline for comparing performance between CNN and Transformer architectures.
▪️ StyleGAN / StyleGAN2
-
Overview: High-fidelity image generation models with controllable style representations.
-
Relation to TransGAN: Serves as a benchmark for attempts to reproduce or exceed style control using Transformer structures (e.g., Styleformer).
▪️ BigGAN
-
Overview: Designed for high-resolution image generation using large-scale datasets like ImageNet.
-
Relation to TransGAN: Often discussed as a performance goal for Transformer-based models seeking scalable and high-quality outputs.
▪️ Progressive GAN
-
Overview: Improves stability and quality by progressively growing image resolution during training.
-
Relation to TransGAN: Influenced TransGAN’s approach to scalable learning, as Transformer structures also benefit from progressive or hierarchical training strategies.
These traditional GANs represent milestones in CNN-based generative modeling, and play a key role in evaluating the effectiveness of novel Transformer-only models like TransGAN. They establish benchmarks in:
-
DCGAN: Basic performance
-
StyleGAN: Image quality and control
-
BigGAN: Scalability and resolution
-
Progressive GAN: Training stability and growth strategy
TransGAN builds upon these insights to explore how far image generation can advance without CNNs, making it both a continuation and a departure from prior paradigms.
Implementation
1. Environment Setup (PyTorch)
Before implementing TransGAN, ensure the following Python environment is properly configured:
Recommended Environment
-
Python 3.8 or later
-
PyTorch 1.9 or later
-
CUDA 10.2+ (for GPU acceleration, optional but recommended)
-
Development environment: VSCode, Jupyter Notebook, or Colab
1. environment construction (PyTorch)
pip install torch torchvision
2. simple implementation of Generator (based on Transformer)
import torch
import torch.nn as nn
class TransformerGenerator(nn.Module):
def __init__(self, latent_dim=128, img_size=32, patch_size=4, dim=256, depth=6, heads=4):
super().__init__()
num_patches = (img_size // patch_size) ** 2
self.patch_size = patch_size
self.img_size = img_size
self.dim = dim
self.latent_proj = nn.Linear(latent_dim, num_patches * dim)
self.transformer = nn.TransformerEncoder(
nn.TransformerEncoderLayer(d_model=dim, nhead=heads), num_layers=depth
)
self.out_proj = nn.Linear(dim, patch_size * patch_size * 3)
def forward(self, z): # z: (batch, latent_dim)
batch = z.shape[0]
tokens = self.latent_proj(z).view(batch, -1, self.dim) # (batch, N, dim)
tokens = self.transformer(tokens) # (batch, N, dim)
patches = self.out_proj(tokens) # (batch, N, patch_pixels)
patches = patches.view(batch, self.img_size, self.img_size, 3).permute(0, 3, 1, 2)
return patches # (batch, 3, H, W)
3. simple implementation of Discriminator (ViT style)
class TransformerDiscriminator(nn.Module):
def __init__(self, img_size=32, patch_size=4, dim=256, depth=6, heads=4):
super().__init__()
num_patches = (img_size // patch_size) ** 2
self.patch_embed = nn.Conv2d(3, dim, kernel_size=patch_size, stride=patch_size)
self.transformer = nn.TransformerEncoder(
nn.TransformerEncoderLayer(d_model=dim, nhead=heads), num_layers=depth
)
self.classifier = nn.Linear(dim, 1)
def forward(self, x): # x: (batch, 3, H, W)
patches = self.patch_embed(x) # (batch, dim, H', W')
tokens = patches.flatten(2).transpose(1, 2) # (batch, N, dim)
out = self.transformer(tokens) # (batch, N, dim)
global_token = out.mean(dim=1) # (batch, dim)
return self.classifier(global_token).squeeze(1) # (batch,)
4. training overview (pseudo code)
G = TransformerGenerator()
D = TransformerDiscriminator()
z = torch.randn(64, 128)
fake_images = G(z)
real_images = next(iter(data_loader)) # CIFAR-10など
# discriminator loss
real_score = D(real_images)
fake_score = D(fake_images.detach())
loss_D = -torch.mean(real_score) + torch.mean(fake_score)
# generator loss
loss_G = -torch.mean(D(fake_images))
Application Examples
Below are specific application examples of TransGAN (Transformer-based GAN):
1. Low-Resolution Image Generation (e.g., CIFAR-10, CelebA)
-
Targets unconditional generation of low-resolution images (32×32 to 64×64).
-
Successfully generates natural images without using any CNN.
-
Applied to datasets such as CIFAR-10 and CelebA.
-
Used as an ablation benchmark to eliminate CNN dependency.
2. Benchmarking Transformer-Based Architectures
-
Evaluates the effectiveness of Transformer architectures for image generation.
-
Serves as a baseline for comparison with models like ViTGAN, GANformer, and Styleformer.
-
Tests how far generation quality can go without relying on CNN’s inductive biases.
3. Visualization and Interpretability of Generation
-
Utilizes attention mechanisms to visually interpret the generation process.
-
Potentially less of a black box than traditional CNN-based models.
-
Applied in domains like medical imaging and anomaly detection for reliability evaluation.
4. Unified Use with General Transformer Models
-
Enables unified Transformer-based construction of both generation (TransGAN) and classification (ViT).
-
Promotes modular reusability across generation, classification, and transformation tasks.
-
Pretrained Transformer modules can be fine-tuned for further applications.
5. Foundation for New GAN Architecture Design
-
Serves as a foundation for CNN-free generative model research.
-
Opens pathways for integration with other models like UNet and Diffusion models.
-
Used as an experimental platform for extended models like TransGAN2 and StyleSwin for high-resolution generation.
6. Evaluation of Generation Quality and Representation Learning
-
Supports evaluation using metrics like Inception Score (IS) and Frechet Inception Distance (FID).
-
Achieved FID ≈ 8.6 on CIFAR-10 with TransGAN-128.
-
Demonstrates significantly better performance than traditional CNN-based models like DCGAN (FID ≈ 26).
References
Below is a curated list of references related to TransGAN (Transformer-based GAN), categorized by original paper, related studies, foundational theory, and implementation resources:
1. Original Paper (TransGAN Core)
Jiang, Yifan, et al. (2021)
Title: TransGAN: Two Transformers Can Make One Strong GAN
-
The first GAN composed entirely of Transformers without using any CNNs
-
Achieved high-quality image generation on datasets like CIFAR-10 and CelebA
🔗 GitHub Repository
2. Related Research (Transformer × GAN)
Hudson & Zitnick (2021)
Title: Generative Adversarial Transformers
-
Combines self-attention and cross-attention in a Transformer-GAN hybrid architecture (CNN included)
Touvron et al. (2020)
Title: DeiT: Data-efficient Image Transformers
-
Lightweight training technique for Vision Transformers (ViT)
-
Influenced the design of TransGAN’s Discriminator
3. Foundational Theory / Technical Background
Dosovitskiy, Alexey, et al. (2020)
Title: An Image is Worth 16×16 Words: Transformers for Image Recognition at Scale
-
The foundational ViT paper, introducing patch tokenization and positional embeddings
🔗 arXiv:2010.11929
Goodfellow, Ian, et al. (2014)
Title: Generative Adversarial Nets
-
The original GAN paper, which TransGAN reimagines using Transformer architectures
🔗 NIPS 2014 PDF
4. Implementation Resources & Tutorials
-
Official PyTorch implementation of TransGAN
-
Tutorial and overview of Vision Transformer applications
-
Benchmark scores and performance metrics for TransGAN
コメント